Best Square Toe Insoles

The age-old debate between square Toe and Round to shoes, well round toes are definitely more popular and socially accepted, whereas square toe shoes are slowly making their way up.

Square Toe shoes, let’s face it are not the most popular style, although they do have some exceptional benefits. Square Toe shoes are likewise not that easy to come by, and when it comes to comfortable or replacement insoles for your square toe shoes it becomes much more difficult to find.

In this article I have listed some of the best available and most comfortable insoles that are designed specifically for Square Toe Boots and Shoes!

square Toe Insole feature

Why Wear a Square Toe Shoe or Boot

square Toe Shoes

Square Toe Shoes and boots are fast becoming more popular, mainly because of their many health benefits;

  • They are much more comfortable for individuals with foot abnormalities such as, swollen feet, hammer toe, or other deformities.
  • Most Square Toe shoes or boots have a much wider toe box area which allows more toe room for additional arch support or an insole.
  • A square toe shoe or boot is similarly likely to have a lower heel which is much more healthy for your feet.
  • Many cowboy boot styles come in a square toe option which can look pretty stylish and elegant on both men and women.
  • In general a square toe boot or shoe offers the ideal fit for individuals with a wider foot, and are a much better option if you have a flat foot or low arch.
  • You can also correct visual flaws on your feet with a square toe, particularly when you have very long feet, they can give the illusion of a smaller or shorter foot.

Unfortunately most square toe shoes and boot are designed for style and not really for comfort, therefore a good square toe design insole could be just what you need with those fancy but uncomfortable pair of square tie dress, or even casual shoes. Or maybe you just need a replacement sole for your square toe boots.

Ariat is a brand that manufactures high quality Western styled boots, shoes and other shoe accessories, if you own a pair of these I am sure that you want the quality and comfort to last, so I have included some excellent options in square toe insoles specifically for your square Toe Ariat boots.

Buying the Right Square Toe Insole

Whether you are buying replacement insoles, or just insoles for comfort and pain relief, here are a few tips on choosing the right Square Toe Insoles for your shoes, or boot;

  • Make sure that the size is right for your specific shoes in width and length, though there may be some options that can be trimmed to fit.
  • Get the right insole for your shoe, some universal models are available, while others are made for specific shoe brands, such as the Ariat brand.
  • Check the placement, for most full-length insoles you will need to remove your existing insole, and vice versa, make sure when you are looking for a replacement insole that it is a replacement and not just a top insert.
  • There are three arch types, low, neutral and high, and each requires specific arch support, make sure that the arch supports the insole offers is right for your arch type.
  • The material is likewise important, insoles are usually made from foam, EVA, Cork Or leather. These are all good options each with its own unique features.
  • A breathable design, and moisture wicking and antimicrobial top layer qualities are excellent to have to keep your feet dry and fresh.

Features of a Good Square toe Insole

  • A Wide or Narrow sized square toe depending on the size of the toe on your shoe or boot.
  • Comfortable and cushioned with some arch support.
  • A moisture-wicking and antibacterial top coat.
  • Perforation Holes, or a breathable and lightweight design.
  • Durable materials and construction.
  • Well cushioned yet not too bulky.
  • Trim to fit, or sizes available.
  • Washable and reusable.
  • Gel padding for impact resistance and shock absorbency.
  • A non-friction top cover.

Reviews: The Best Square Toe Insoles


We all know the superior shoe and boot brand that is Ariat, well now they also have specialized insoles made to fit square toe boots like a glove.

  • Manufactured from highly durable and supportive 100% polyurethane.
  • Features a Wide and square toe, ideal for square toe boots and work boots.
  • The Gel heel and Foot Pads offer exceptional cushioning and shock absorbency at high-pressure areas.
  • Improved comfort and support with the ATS technology.
  • Lightweight and breathable to keep your feet dry and comfortable in your favorite square toe shoes or boots.


The ideal comfort insole to replace your worn out insoles on your favorite pair of boots. Twisted X offers you a full footbed insole that can easily replace an old worn out insole or footbed.

  • A full SD Trade Footbed insole to replace an old footbed or insole.
  • Features a square toe to fit most square toe boots.
  • They are cushioned for comfort and highly supportive.
  • It is covered with a moisture wicking and antimicrobial lining to keep your feet dry and odor free.
  • Completely machine washable and reusable.


An insole designed specifically for men with active lifestyles, the Ariat Insole with Quantum Technology offers you all day support and comfort.

  • Manufactured from high grade, durable Polyurethane that is 100% pure.
  • Easily hand washable and air dry for your convenience.
  • Breathable and durable construction for dry and comfortable feet.
  • The Quantum Technology offers your comfort and support where you need it the most, for men who are active on their feet.


If you are looking for an extra bit of comfort and cushioning in your dress shoes or boots, the ComfySole inserts are just what you need, they offer a trim to fit option in a square toe for both men’s and women’s square toe shoes.

  • Extremely soft and comfortable allowing you to wear uncomfortable shoes, comfortably.
  • Excellent quality inserts that fit easily into most square toe shoes.
  • Available in different sizes, and can be trimmed to fit, to fit into any shoe of your choice snugly.
  • Well cushioned without extra bulk.
  • Offers exceptional support and good shock absorbency.


One for the ladies. The ATS technology Ariat square Toe Insole offers exceptional comfort and support for your square toe boots.

  • Manufactured from highly durable and comfortable Polyurethane materials.
  • Features a moisture-wicking and top antibacterial layer to keep feet dry and fresh all day.
  • The ATS Technology ensures only the best-targeted support and cushioned comfort for your feet.
  • Gel heel pads absorb shock and prevent heel pain.
  • A wide square toe for the wider toe boot.
  • Easily hand washable and reusable for your convenience.

In Conclusion

Looking for those perfect Square Toe insoles for your favorite square toe boots or shoes may be quite a daunting task, as Square toe shoes and boots are not at the top of the list when it comes to popularity.

Though square toe shoes and boots have many idealistic benefits to both men and women, you may still require a comfortable and supportive insole, with a square toe that is of course.

The list I have given features some of the highest quality and most comfortable insoles that are ideal for a variety of square toe boots and shoes for both men and women.

Index Table: Top Rated Square Toe Insoles

1Ariat Unisex ATS - Square Toe Insoles for Boots
  • Gel Pads
  • ATS Technology
2Twisted X Unisex Boots - Square Toe Footbed Insole
  • Moisture Wicking
  • Antimicrobial
Twisted X97
3Ariat Men's Quantum - Men’s Ariat Boot Insoles
  • Square Toe
  • Machine Washable
  • Cushioned
4ComfySole Unisex Comfort - Square Toe Insoles for Support
  • Trim to Fit
  • Cushioned
5Ariat Women's ATS - Square Toe Boot Insoles
  • Gel Heel
  • ATS Technology

Please Rate This Article:

  • 5/5
  • 3 ratings
3 ratingsX
Very bad!BadHmmmOkeGood!